Radon and Radioactivity - Facts and ControversiesItems:
- Radon mitigation stacks - worse than Chernobyl?
- Radon potions
- The discovery of radon in homes
- Avoid radioactive rain from radon clouds!
- Government cover-up of the dangers of radioactivity
- Radiation as the cure-all miracle
- Radiation has caused most cancers and heart diseases
- See alpha particle in action!
- Dog saves people from radon
- Radioactive fallout from uranium mines
- Uranium's deadly legacy
- Radioactive homes
- The saga of radium dial painters
- Radon - the killer in tobacco
- Russian Mafia uses radioactivity
- A little carcinogen might be good for you!
- Stimulate your natural cancer defenses!
- EPA has underestimated the dangers of radon
- Fallout from Nevada nuclear bomb tests
- DU helmets for our generals?
- Fascinating Facts - Part 2
The explosion and fire at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant in Ukraine evaporated 8 tons of nuclear fuel and ejected radioactive graphite and dust high into the atmosphere. Winds spread radioactive iodine and cesium over most of the Northern Hemisphere. The accident, kept secret by the Soviet government, was discovered when workers entering a nuclear plant in Sweden triggered radioactivity alarms. The total radioactive release out of the bounds of Chernobyl was estimated at 50 million Curies.
The US EPA estimates that 6 to 8 million homes exceed the radon "action limit" of 4 pCi/L. What if all these homeowners installed fan-based radon mitigation? Underground radon levels range from 200 to 2,000 pCi/L and average 1,000 pCi/L. With a 70 cfm fan, the typical radon stack emits 1 Curie of radioactivity per year (equivalent to 1 gram of radium). The total radioactivity released each year by all these radon stacks would amount to 6 - 8 million Curies. This is comparable to a Chernobyl-size nuclear disaster occurring in the U.S. every seven years! Moreover, the radon emissions would be concentrated in populated areas. Radon gas, being 8 times heavier than air (like steel versus water), tends to settle near the house. While the radioactive iodine from Chernobyl decayed in days, the decay of radon's radioactive daughter products into stable lead takes over 22 years.
(Comment: It is always better to mitigate - radon in homes causes many more deaths in the U.S. each year than the total death toll of Chernobyl. However, a radon mitigation method that leaves the gas in the ground would be preferable.)
A San Francisco company ushered in a craze in radioactive health crocks in 1912, when it was granted a patent for "Revigorator". This device saturated water with radon and people were advised to drink six or more glasses each day. "Radithor", a quack radon potion to cure sexual dysfunction and everything else, was introduced in 1925. After several years, people started dying of the effects of this potion. The manufacturer and user of Radithor died 14 years later of bladder cancer. No warnings to the public were ever issued.
Hundreds of thousands of health-conscious Americans drank bottled water laced with radium as a general elixir, known popularly as "liquid sunshine." Soon, radioactive toothpaste was marketed, then radioactive skin cream. Chocolate bars containing radium were sold as a "rejuvenator." As recently as 1952, LIFE magazine wrote about the beneficial effects of inhaling radioactive radon gas in Montana mines. Even today, people visit the radon-filled mines and report multiple benefits. However, numerous studies have concluded that the only demonstrable health effect of inhaling radon is lung cancer.
In 1984, the scientific world woke up to the existence of radon in homes. A construction engineer triggered radiation alarms while entering the Limerick nuclear power plant near Philadelphia. His home in Boyertown was tested and the radon concentration was a shocking 2,700 pCi/L.
The family, including small children, was immediately evacuated. Very high radon levels were also found in nearby houses. This region, known as the Reading Prong, has low-grade uranium deposits and encompasses parts of Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and New York.
Workers entering the Super Collider at the Argonne National Laboratory near Chicago used to trigger radioactivity alarms when it rained. It was discovered that rainwater deposited on their shoes and hands carried radioactive decay products of radon. The laboratory developed special radiation monitors to detect the specific gamma rays emitted by radon progeny in rain clouds. During the first year of operation the alarm was triggered nine times. Since the radon alarms occurred simultaneously at two monitors approximately 1,000 meters apart, it proved that large radon-saturated clouds are regularly passing over populated areas. It confirmed that radon released by wastes from uranium mines in the West can travel hundreds of miles across America.
Source: Health Physics, November 1999
About 600,000 workers were exposed to radioactive materials in 14 nuclear weapons plants since the beginning of the Manhattan Project. Their radiation exposure was within the official "safety limits." However, increased rates of leukemia, cancers, vision difficulties, chronic fatigue syndrome and other health problems have been observed. The identified 22 types of cancers include cancer of the lung, prostate, bladder, kidney, and Hodgkin's lymphoma. Some scientists believe that radiation damages the human immune system, leaving people vulnerable to a wide range of other diseases.
Until 1999, the U.S. government disputed reports that low-level ionizing radiation is harmful. DOE and DOD waged media campaigns against "fear mongers" and spent tens of millions of dollars on lawyers. Then, after decades of denials, the government finally conceded that the radiation exposure to workers at nuclear weapons plants caused a wide range of cancers. President Clinton apologized to the "heroes of the nuclear age." But by then, many have died. The US Congress agreed to pay out $150.000 to each of the sick survivors, but denied them unlimited healthcare. Although private companies ran many of these plants for profit, the U.S. taxpayers will pick up the tab.
Source: The New York Times, January 29, 2000
(Comments: There is no plan to change the old safety limits - paying out compensation is much more cost-effective than lowering the limits throughout the whole nuclear complex. However, being a homeowner is still riskier - the radiation exposure of an average worker over several years of employment is American from radon at home.)
Within months after Wilhem Roentgen donated x-rays to the world in 1895, medical doctors used it on patients for all possible ailments. (Antibiotics had not been discovered yet.) The early x-ray machines imparted huge radiation doses. There was no reason to expect any harm from this miracle of modern science. Then, fluoroscopes ("x-ray movies") were invented, which multiplied the radiation dose. Until 1950's, radiologists tested the set-up of a x-ray machine by holding a hand in front of it to observe how soon it gets red. Many doctors developed radiation burns or even lost their fingers but they did not start dying of cancer until decades later.
When radium became widely available, radon gas expanded the radiation arsenal - it is vented off a piece of radium. Radon emits gamma rays (just like x-rays but more energetic) in addition to alpha and beta particles. Medical Life magazine claimed in 1925 that radon treatment cured at least 27 illnesses. Radiation was prescribed for heart trouble, cancer, arthritis, high blood pressure, tuberculosis, blindness, back problems, herpes, bronchial asthma, peptic ulcers, and impotence.
Embryos received x-ray doses already in the womb during abdominal exams. Newborns were routinely treated by x-rays to prevent diseases. Pediatricians used to fluoroscope babies and young children every month and during annual checkups. Many children were given massive radiation treatment for an invented disorder - enlargement of the thymus gland in the upper chest. The scalps of 10,000 New York children were irradiated to make their hair fall out as a treatment for ringworm. Depression in women was cured by irradiating the ovaries and excessive bleeding of girls during menstruation by x-rays to the uterus. Primitive mammography caused the breast cancer epidemic decades later.
Mass screenings of children for tuberculosis in the 50's sent buses with crude x-ray machines to schools throughout the country. Fluoroscopes became the fad for fitting shoes in stores. Doctors and local beauty shops used radiation for acne and unwanted hair or freckles. Dermatologists used x-ray treatments until the 70's. These deadly practices were not stopped by our pro-nuclear government but only by negative publicity in the media.
Until 1920's, lung cancer was extremely rare. When a physician discovered a case, all interns were called because they would not see another case for years to come. The lung cancer epidemic in the second half of the century increased the lung cancer rate from 4 in 100,000 people to 72 in 100,000 in 1990. Coronary heart diseases also increased dramatically.
Dr. John Gofman, a prominent radiologist who helped to build the first nuclear bombs, concluded that medical irradiation has caused most of the cancers and coronary heart diseases in the twentieth century. He studied mortality rates from 1940 to 1990 of the entire U.S. population. He found that the mortality rates for cancers and coronary heart disease increase proportionally with the number of physicians per 100,000 people in each region, while all other diseases decrease. More physicians in a region means more x-rays to its population. In the case of coronary heart disease, the cause appears to be radiation-induced mutations in the coronary arteries.
Statistical analysis shows that medical irradiation has caused over a half of all cancers, two thirds of coronary heart diseases, and over 80% of breast cancers in the US. Dr. Gofman stresses that the radiation from each medical or dental x-ray can be reduced several-fold without sacrificing accuracy. All x-ray machines should be regularly calibrated and the doses measured. People should refuse unnecessary x-rays.
John W. Gofman, M.D., Ph.D. 1999: Radiation from Medical Procedures in the Pathogenesis of Cancer and Ischemic Heart Disease
To see a photograph of the tracks of an alpha particle (as released by radon) in lungs click here!
Back in the late 80's, I had a client whose dog died prematurely. They took it to the vet and x-rays showed the dog died from lung cancer. They then tested their home and found radon concentrations of 150 pCi/l! The owners stated that their dog probably saved their lives.
Source: Jay Bauder, Bauder Basement Systems, Inc
About a ton of ore is required to extract two pounds of uranium. Huge quantities of pulverized rock (uranium tailings) are left over from the milling process. They contain thorium, radium, and all the other uranium by-products and retain 85 per cent of the ore's original radioactivity. The tailings give off at least 10,000 times as much radon gas as the undisturbed ore. Radon atoms produced inside hard rock have a low chance to escape from the grain, but when the rock is pulverized, radon gas escapes easily.
Each uranium mine is spreading radioactive poisons over vast areas of the earth, as the Chernobyl disaster or atmospheric nuclear tests have done, but at a slower rate. With only a light breeze, radon gas can travel thousand miles in a few days. Being eight times heavier than air, radon travels low to the ground and deposits its "daughters" - solid radioactive fallout - on the vegetation, soil and water below. These radioactive particles enter the food chain, ending up in fruits and berries, the flesh of fish and animals, and ultimately, in the bodies of human beings.
Radium dust is blown in the wind, washed by the rain, and leached from the tailings piles into waterways. It re-concentrates by factors of thousands in aquatic plants and by factors of hundreds in land plants. A front page article in the Wall Street Journal (February 25, 1986) described the 220 million tons of uranium tailings in the U.S. as an ecological and financial time bomb. (Canada has about 150 million tons of tailings.) Uranium tailings will remain dangerously radioactive for millions of years.
Source: Uranium: The Deadliest Metal
(Comment: Under the Uranium Mill Tailings Remedial Action Program, the Department of Energy is covering the tailings with a layer of soil to reduce the release of radon.)
At the gateway of one of America's most popular wilderness recreation areas lies a ticking time bomb. Colorado River, winding around Moab in Utah, carries drinking water to millions of people in Utah, Nevada, Arizona and Southern California. But it also carries radioactive contaminants.
An abandoned uranium mill near Moab has left behind 10.5 million tons of uranium tailings, which are steadily leaking toxins into the groundwater and the river. Wells in the area reveal very high radioactivity in the groundwater. Fish with elevated radioactivity levels are showing up. The tailings are also releasing large quantities of radon gas into the air. The tailings pile could be compromised by floods, erosion or seismic activity.
National Parks and Conservation Association, eMagazine May-June 1998 - Uranium's Legacy
Mining companies pump chemical solutions into the ground to dissolve and wash out uranium salts, polluting underground waters with chemicals and radioactivity. Over three billion cubic feet of wastes from uranium mining still await proper disposal. These waste heaps are persistent sources of water-soluble radium salts and airborne radon gas. Thousands of tons of ore were transported for processing to areas near major population centers, like Niagara Falls, Salt Lake City, Cincinnati and Chicago. Some of the radioactive mining wastes were used to make concrete for houses, buildings and roads.
Meter Conversions, Inc: Radioactivity detector
In the Southwest U.S. and in Port Hope, Ontario, many homes and schools were built using sand-like tailings from uranium mines as construction material. Some of these buildings ended up with radon levels higher than those permitted in mines. Similar (though less severe) radon problems arose in Florida and Newfoundland when phosphate tailings were used for construction.
Source: Uranium: The Deadliest Metal
Shortly after its discovery radium was used to make luminous paints. During World War I, hundreds of young women in New York and Illinois were applying the highly radioactive paint to aircraft instrument dials. Radium painting expanded to "glow-in-the-dark" clocks and watches.
The young women who applied the paint frequently licked the brush to keep it pointed and their work area was saturated in radon. Suspicions arose in the late 1920's over jaw cancers among the dial painters, as their tragic saga slowly started to unfold. Initially, the plant managers accused the women of bad hygiene. Years later, most of these women died of cancer.
During World War II, young women painted radium on military instruments, so that the dials would glow in the darkness of a cockpit. Precautions were now taken to avoid the ingestion of radium, but the danger of the released radon gas was not understood. Cancer has killed many of these women during the following 20-30 years.
Since the mid 1960's, the watch manufacturers are using Tritium, a radioactive form of hydrogen with a half-life of 12 years, or Promethium, a man-made radioactive element with a half-life of 2.6 years. Both of these elements are weak beta and gamma emitters but only few of the particles penetrate the cover glass of the watch.
Out of the nearly 4,000 chemicals found in tobacco smoke, only two definite chemical carcinogens have been found - benzopyrine and nitrosamine. However, the most potent carcinogen in tobacco is radiation from the radioactive products of radon. Polonium-210 is the only component of cigarette smoke that has produced cancers by itself in laboratory animals by inhalation - tumors appear at a level five times lower than the dose to a heavy smoker.
Lung cancer rates among men kept climbing from a rarity in 1930 (4/100,000 per year) to the No. 1 cancer killer in 1980 (72/100,000) in spite of an almost 20 percent reduction in smoking. But during the same period, the level of polonium-210 in American tobacco had tripled. This coincided with the increase in the use of phosphate fertilizers by tobacco growers - calcium phosphate ore accumulates uranium and slowly releases radon gas.
As radon decays, its electrically charged daughter products attach themselves to dust particles, which adhere to the sticky hairs on the underside of tobacco leaves. This leaves a deposit of radioactive polonium and lead on the leaves. Then, the intense localized heat in the burning tip of a cigarette volatilizes the radioactive metals. While cigarette filters can trap chemical carcinogens, they are ineffective against radioactive vapors.
The lungs of a chronic smoker end up with a radioactive lining in a concentration much higher than from residential radon. These particles emit radiation. Smoking two packs of cigarettes a day imparts a radiation dose by alpha particles of about 1,300 millirem per year. (IEM) For comparison, the annual radiation dose to the average American from inhaled radon is 200 mrem. However, the radiation dose at the radon "action level" of 4 pCi/L is roughly equivalent to smoking 10 cigarettes a day.
Philip Morris scientists wondered how come that the heavy tobacco users in the Caucasus live remarkably long lives. The local tobacco growers do not use phosphate fertilizers. But the American smoker inhales on average about 0.04 pCi of polonium-210 per cigarette, which disgorges alpha particles. It has a half life of only 138 days, making it thousand times more radioactive than the nuclear fuel used in the Hiroshima bomb.
Polunium-210 is soluble and is circulated through the body to every tissue and cell in levels much higher than from residential radon. The proof is that it can be found in the blood and urine of smokers. The circulating polonium-210 causes genetic damage and early death from diseases reminiscent of early radiological pioneers: liver and bladder cancers, stomach ulcers, leukemias, cirrhosis of liver, and cardiovascular diseases.
The Center for Disease Control concluded "Americans are exposed to far more radiation from tobacco smoke than from any other source." The Surgeon General C. Everett Koop stated that radioactivity, rather than tar, accounts for at least 90% of all smoking-related lung cancers.
Cigarette smoking accounts for 30% of all cancer deaths. Only poor diet rivals tobacco smoke as a cause of cancer in the U.S., causing a comparable number of fatalities each year. However, the National Cancer Institute, with an annual budget of $500 million, has no active funding for research of radiation from smoking or residential radon as a cause of lung cancer, presumably, to protect the public from "undue fears of radiation."
The government and nuclear industry financed practically all the research on dangers of nuclear radiation. The scientists obligingly produced studies that the dangers of low-level radiation could not be proven, which were then widely disseminated to the public by collaborating media. Most attacked was the Linear No-Threshold (LNT) Model, which says that there is no safe threshold for exposure to radiation. This threatened the established "safety limits." According to Prof. Cohen, the apostle of pro-nuke science, low-level exposure to radioactivity or chemical carcinogens stimulates the body's defenses against cancer. For example, increasing the radon level in homes to 5 pCi/L should reduce the lung cancer risk. His comments reveal how the radon issue is connected to much larger multi-billion dollar issues:
"If Low Level Radiation was properly recognized as harmless, it would have a vast impact on many wasteful multi-billion government programs and regulations: the clean-up of the Hanford, Savannah River, Rocky Flats, and other sites; nuclear plant safety; routine emissions of radioactivity from nuclear plants; radioactive waste storage; and reduction of radon levels in homes. It would also make moot the issues of the 10,000 to 20,000 deaths projected from the Chernobyl accident, the fallout from nuclear bomb tests, and patients' fears of x-rays." "The simplistic LNT model has been also applied to chemical carcinogens, leading to severe restrictions on the use of cleaning fluids, organic chemicals, pesticides, etc. If the LNT model were abandoned for radon, it should be also abandoned for chemical carcinogens."
- Increase your radon level to 5 pCi/L - buy the pure Mountain Fresh Radon!
- Drink radon-enriched mineral water! (Proven effective since 1920's.)
- Sprinkle some asbestos, lead and arsenic around your home!
- Light up 12 cigarettes a day!
- Visit our combination tanning and x-ray health salon!
- Wear a genuine radium pendant just like Madame Curie!
The linear hypothesis used by the EPA seriously underestimates the risk of lung cancer at low exposures to radon. In fact, the relative lung cancer risk increases for lower radon exposures. Alpha radiation is more effective in causing cancer at low dose rates. Higher doses cause overkill - cells that would have developed into cancer cells are instead killed. Studies of uranium miners clearly demonstrate the increasing effectiveness of radon exposure at low doses.
The gradual build-up of long-lived radon daughters in the lung, such as lead-210 with its 21-year half-life, makes it highly unlikely that extra cancers would stop appearing after 20 years. Lead-210 decays into polonium-210, whose potent carcinogenic properties are well documented. Long follow-up periods of 20-25 years among miners show that the incidence of cancers for nonsmokers sometimes exceeds that of smokers. Moreover, non-smokers who started mining at an early age begin to show dramatic increases in lung cancer some 40 or 50 years after the initial exposure.
Radon daughters, in addition to alpha and beta particles, also emit gamma rays. The health risk from exposure to the low level gamma radiation from radon includes not only cancers and genetic defects, but also possible increases in such diseases as diabetes milletus, cardiovascular disease, mental retardation, stroke, hypertension, and a great many infectious diseases.
Dr. Gordon Edwards: Estimating Lung Cancers
During 1951-1962, nearly 100 aboveground nuclear weapons tests were conducted in Nevada. Another dozen underground tests also leaked radioactive materials into atmosphere. Rising public concern, as well as mounting litigation, led to the atmospheric test-ban treaty of 1963.
The U.S. government had assured the public that the nuclear tests were harmless. However, the Atomic Energy Commission "experts" overlooked how radioactive fallout gets into the food chain. Radioactive clouds travel hundreds of miles and after the fallout rains on grass, feeding cattle produces radioactive milk. This had exposed millions to radioactivity, particularly children. Some scientists calculated that the nuclear tests killed 400,000 American children. Government scientists rebutted that the nuclear bomb testing killed "only" 4,000 children.
The NCI report on the fallout from Nevada tests was not published until 1997, after it was kept secret for six years. It dealt only with iodine-131 and admitted that tens of thousands of Americans have received cumulative exposure of over 100 rem. ("Rem" is a measure of the ability of ionizing radiation to cause cancer or genetic defects in children of exposed people. Natural radioactivity is about 0.1 rem/year.) The highest exposures were to young children who drank milk. It has caused estimated 49,000 cases of thyroid cancer which, however, is rarely deadly.
The National Research Council: Exposure from Nevada Nuclear-Bomb Tests
In 1950's, our generals marched thousands of GI's through the "ground zero" after atom bomb tests and showered our sailors with nuclear fallout to prove that radiation is harmless. Now, they insist that ammunition tipped with depleted uranium (DU) is relatively harmless. DU is 1.7 times as dense as lead and easily burns its way through steel. But most of our NATO allies want DU munitions banned.
DU is the waste left after extracting the isotope U-235 from uranium ore for nuclear weapons or reactors. While 99.3 percent of natural uranium is U-238, enrichment reduces the U-235 content in the leftover "depleted uranium" from 0.7 to 0.2 percent and makes it 40 percent less radioactive. But we are now stuck with over 1 million tons of DU waste.
The Gulf War I marked the first battlefield use of armor-piercing DU munitions and DU-reinforced armor. But the generals did not anticipate "friendly fire" accidents - U.S. tanks firing DU munitions into other U.S. combat vehicles (Bradleys). When a DU projectile hits steel, the high temperature vaporizes the uranium and exposes the survivors, as well as rescuers, to radioactive aerosol and dust. And wind can carry DU particles (less than 10 microns) for many miles. Soldiers were also exposed to DU inhalation when DU munitions burned and detonated at Camp Doha in Kuwait.
About 162 surviving soldiers had embedded DU fragments or inhaled DU particles. Most continue to excrete elevated levels of uranium, exhibit reduced problem-solving performance and have high levels of hormones harmful to reproductive health. Uranium has been found in the semen of some veterans.
When soldiers return from a modern, DU-improved war, they cannot be certain for decades whether or not they have really survived. DU exposes soldiers to low-level radiation and also produces radon, which can accumulate inside vehicles or buildings. The military has kept denying that DU has harmful radiological effects until confronted by Congress. Thus, U.S. troops were not warned that inhalation of uranium dust might cause lung cancer and birth defects in their children until 1999!
A single "hot particle" trapped in the lungs subjects the surrounding cells to radiation 800 times the dosage permitted by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) for the entire body. The risk is equivalent to getting a chest X-ray each hour for life! Some 80,000 US Gulf War veterans now suffer from the so-called Gulf War syndrome, whose symptoms are identical to radiation sickness.
In addition to being radioactive, DU is toxic. The genetic damage to DNA from chemical toxicity or radioactivity, or both, can be inherited and passed along to successive generations. So harm may not become apparent until several generations after the DU-exposure. This puts DU munitions into the class of weapons known as "weapons of mass destruction or indiscriminate effect."
After U.S. aircraft used DU munitions in Bosnia, Kosovo, Serbia and Montenegro, the cancer deaths of 24 European peacekeepers and illnesses of many others have caused alarm in Europe. The military has pledged to Puerto Rico not to use DU munitions on Vieques, but has recently admitted mistakes.
There is a long-term devastating effect on the people we have liberated and their environment. The waste remains radioactive for thousands of years. We have dumped 350 tons of DU on Iraq, Kuwait, and Saudi Arabia and some 1 million bullets still rest in the desert. There has been an increase in lung, kidney and liver cancer, birth defects and stillbirths. Much of Kosovo's ground water has been contaminated and a cleanup would cost billions of dollars. (NYT 1/6/01)
A military contractor, making DU weapons, dumped DU into an unlined pit in the ground in downtown Concord, Mass. Now soil in Concord is contaminated with DU as far as a mile from the dump, and local wells are contaminated because DU has moved into groundwater. Shortly before this radioactive dump was added to the national Superfund list, the company directors declared bankruptcy and, so U.S. taxpayers are now paying for the difficult cleanup. (Ed Ericson, "Dumping on History: A Radioactive Nightmare in Concord, Massachusetts," E/The Environmental Magazine Mar. 5, 2004)
It was discovered only recently that DU fragments quickly disintegrate into a fine powder like cigarette ash. (NYT 9/2/02) Wind then blows this radioactive dust around for people and animals to inhale, contaminating the soil and water in a large area.
In the first Gulf War, US forces used 320 tons of DU, 80 percent of it fired by A-10 aircraft. According to Pentagon, the tonnage has been much lower in Gulf War II - about 75 tons of A-10 DU bullets. A spent tank round, just like those Iraqi children are playing with, was found to emit 260 millirads of radiation per hour. For comparison, the safety limit on exposure to the public is 100 millirems per year. (Christian Science Monitor 5/15/03)
Is there apractical alternative to DU? Yes! Tungsten-alloy weapons can kill tanks and other hardened targets as effectively as DU.
The Geneva Conventions prohibit weapons, which cause indiscriminate harm to non-combatants, and weapons, which cause widespread, long-term and severe damage to the environment. Will the U.S. taxpayers have to pay to clean up after its military in foreign countries?
Continue to: Fascinating Facts - Part 2